Segregated Beach The Inkwell

Of the many obstacles that Black swimming culture still faces, perhaps the most daunting, is the very notion that it does not exist: that a Black person enjoying the water is anomalous. Because, in fact, it has existed all along. Photo: Courtesy 12 Miles North


The Inertia

In the great and varied canon of American racial stereotypes, there is a highly detailed list of segregated sports. Basketball, for instance, is a “Black” sport. Hockey, on the other hand, is for Whites. Surfing falls firmly into the category of “white sport,” somewhere between mountaineering and golf. It could be argued that there is no “whiter” sport in the world that was originally invented by non-whites. There are many ways to illustrate this, but let’s leave it here: It is the only sport since the 1936 summer Olympics in which the 2009 world champion, Mick Fanning, can say something overtly anti-Semitic to a reporter and the outlet that reports the statement will be blamed for bad taste.

Why don’t Black people surf? That can be answered with another race-based generalization. Black people don’t swim. Consider the numbers: A 2010 study by US Swimming, America’s governing body of competitive swimming, found that nearly half of White children (42 percent) had low or no swimming ability. That number was topped by Hispanic American children; 58 percent of whom reported no or low swimming ability. Black children had the highest non-swimming rates at just under than 70 percent. I suspect that the White numbers are slightly inflated based on the fact many that my Caucasian, land-lubbing friends define “swimming” as walking into a pool up to their waist, getting out, then applying more coconut oil. But that doesn’t change the fact that swimming rates among Black children are abysmal. Infinitely more worrisome is that Black children are around three times more likely to drown than White children, based on another study by US swimming, which is apparently the only organization who studies these sorts of things.

There is one problem with these studies: although the numbers are correct, the conclusion that we causally draw from them is utterly corrupt. The numbers tell us that many Black people don’t swim; Our interpretation, however, is that Black people are not swimmers, which is wrong. The truth is that American Blacks have a long and well-documented history of loving to swim. In order to understand why African American culture does not currently enjoy a well established culture of recreational swimming, we need to delve under the stereotypes and generalizations and look at the history of exclusion that has accompanied their efforts to access the water.

“There were two periods of time in 20th century in which swimming became popularized and democratized in the US,” says Jeff Wiltse, author of the book Contested Waters: A Social History of Swimming Pools in America. “The first was in the 1920s and 1930s. That’s really when swimming as a recreational activity became popular in US. The vehicles of this popularization were the swimming pools being built in inter-war period. However, it was during that time that blacks were being denied access or relegated to pools that couldn’t accommodate very many people or were generally less desirable.”

Wiltse’s book deals with the complex web of segregation that enveloped Black Americans upon their emancipation form slavery. In this web, the municipal swimming pool became ground zero for Jim Crow. When the first pools opened in cities like Philadelphia in the late 19th century, they were considered to be public baths and located in a low-income neighborhood so that people without access to running water could clean themselves. These pools were segregated by sex but integrated as far as race was concerned. One of the first pools to combine the sexes was the Fairgrounds pool in St. Louis, which opened to great fanfare in 1913. By then, the swimming pool had turned from a public hygiene project into a coveted leisure space, which was quickly becoming an American institution. At 440 feet in diameter, the circular Fairgrounds Pool was the largest in the country by a country mile. It was ringed by an artificial sand beach and had an inclined bottom that mimicked the gradual deepening of the sea floor. The recreation department even considered putting a wave machine in but nixed the idea because it was too expensive. On hot summer days, thousands of people packed into the pool. None of them were Black. This was not for lack of desire on the part of Black residents of St Louis. Instead, the pool was forcibly, and at times violently segregated because city officials didn’t want black men interacting with white women in such an intimate space. Wiltse cites the Fairground pool as “one point of origin of the mixed-gender, racially segregated leisure society that came to predominate during the twentieth century.” The fear of black men interacting with white women in swimwear kept pools firmly segregated until the mid 1950s.

When some Black people began to resist the race barrier, either through lawsuits filed with the backing of the NAACP or through actually entering a pool and trying to swim, they were often met with a host of legal tricks, violence, or a combination of the two. A common way of segregating a pool was for the city government to lease the pool to a private company to operate. Although the government couldn’t legally segregate, a private company could make whatever rules it wanted.

In smaller towns, they would often promise angry Black communities their own swimming pool for years without delivering. In 1942, Montgomery, West Virginia closed its only municipal swimming pool for four years instead of permitting interracial swimming. When the Fairground Pool was desegregated in 1949, five thousand White people rioted and indiscriminately beat any Black person they could get their hands on near the park where the pool was located.

1 2
  • ctwalrus

    there were just this week a series of stories in the Atlantic City Press telling the tale of Blacks in the service industry throughout the 150+ years of AC as a coastal resort and the land covants written into the various housing area of the city and surrounding areas.    I recall growing up and both seeing and hearing about the various ‘black beaches’ in jersey coastal towns…….not a nice piece of American history no matter how you look at it………I plan on showing 12 miles North to my oceans classes this  week, the response should be interesting….

  • Igraba

    So what about the real Africans in Africa? Do they love to swim? I happen to live there, on the beach and am black myself. No, the majority of us don’t like to swim. Why do we always have to do everything exactly the same as the white man in America? Maybe we’ll excel in other areas? Chinese don’t really love swimming either, but they can do a ton of stuff most Americans cannot. Calm down and stop looking for a winner. Sometimes it’s not about wrong and right, it’s just different.

    • Bert

       I happen to live in Africa too, from 1970 to 1990, in various west coast countries, and am white myself. I learned to swim with little black kids of my age (3 or 4 years old), and I carry on swimming with them my whole life there, i different countries. I teached numerous black kids or older people to sail or to windsurf, and surfed with some black guys too.
      Of course, without swimming pools and stuff like that, you have to live on the beach to swim, because where I lived, most of the rivers were unfit for swimming.
      I event went twice in South Africa, and witnessed the nazi like apartheid that was the norm there. I didn’t see a single black in the water. Maybe there were some “coloured beaches” somewhere else, but I didn’t see them (Durban and Jburg).
      In different occasions, people there make a connection with the slavery times: fear of water, fear of living close to the sea…

      But I can testify that a lot of black people love to swim and swim on a daily basis on the coast of Africa, from Senegal to Angola.

    • John Smith

      What about the basic survival need? Swimming can be a lifesaver, every parent must ensure their child can swim. Just saying it’s not your thing is not going to help you when you find yourself in the water.

    • zach

      I agree, all races have differences… and how did u learn English so well!?

  • Lobbylyode

    I grew up swimming and surfing with black kids in oz.  Indigenous swimming and surfing in australia  has a long and rich history.
    However, the definite lack of  indigenous professional swimmers in australia is a direct result of segregation.
    Where do you think the south african government got there blue print for aparthied?

  • Sandee D

    I live in Michigan, right on the big lake. I live in a community where it has been majorily black since as early as the 20′s. The beaches have always been open to all races… and black people still can’t swim. So, the “access to a pool” theory is totally inaccurate. I worked the beach as a life guard for years and lived on this beach my whole life and taught people how to swim for 10 years and I can see a definate cultural difference here. Black people are more rigid and tend to “flop around” more, lacking grace in the water. They also PANIC easier. They spook easier, get upset easier, and just lack gracefullness in general. I don’t know how many black children and black ADULTS I have pulled out of the water in my lifetime. It just seems to me that swimming is a natural instinct that comes with being white. It seems like I have always known how to swim. I don’t even remember learning! I think most white people can relate to this as where blacks need to be taught and there have been black people that I tried to teach that just couldn’t be taught. Just saying what I have seen in my 52 years experience… not being racist at all. If I was, I’d just’ve well had let them drown, not save their lives.

    • Bekii Qinan

      I’m African American–so why can me and the majority of my family swim. In fact, my uncle was on a swim team in the 1950s. So you can’t judge every black person in the whole world by your small experience. You may not thing you’re racist but you are ignorant.

    • suprmon

      Didn’t you just read the article? Are you clueless? The article just said that after so many years of blacks being alienated from swimming in beaches and swimming pools, the desire to swim died amongst the African American community. After so many years of being denied something, the normal psychological response is to lose the taste for it! The example you give about your particular experience (if it was true) was the exception, not the rule! And if you felt that way as far as “letting them drown while teaching them” is concerned, why did you even bother teaching them in the first place? They certainly could have done without your valuable services!!!

  • John Smith

    This may all be true but fails to explain why the same phenomenon of swimming being a white thing is duplicated in all non-white cultures such as India and Africa, especially so in places prone to frequent flooding.

  • John Smith

    No-one says non-white people can’t swim, the question is why they never want to learn, even when they know it could save their life.

  • zach

    I agree with igraba

  • zach

    I am white, and have known how to swim since I was 2, and am a very good swimmer, but rarely ever see black people at the pool, or swimming. I also never see many whites playing basketball, or winning many running events in track over black people… I’m pretty sure that God made every race a little different. Black people can obviously run faster and jump higher than white people! (majority). While white people can swim faster and better than black people! (majority)

    • suprmon

      Here we go again with the stereotypes again! I believe anyone can be exceptionally good at whatever they’re passionate about if given the chance and put in the motivation. With those factors anyone can aspire to be the best at anything they set their hearts to regardless of race or gender. So, white men can jump, and also I hear there are African-Americans playing in the NHL now!