Alexander Haro

TheInertia.com Associate Editor

Could Crowds Save Our Planet?

Tuesday, January 3rd, 2012
Clean ocean water to surf in and enjoy in Nicaragua.

Clean water. A beautiful site to behold. And plenty worth protecting... Photo: Patrick Ruddy

I have this theory that surfing is one of the most selfish things a person can do. Of course, there are those moments where surfing with friends is rewarding, and, in fact, I find it almost as fun watching someone get a great wave as I do getting one myself. The operative word there, however, is almost. No matter how rewarding it is watching a friend pull into a great looking wave, I’d rather it was me on it. That’s selfish. I’m selfish when it comes to surfing. And I’m not the only one; surfers scratch for waves, doing things they’d probably never do in a parking lot, dropping in, stealing waves, or claiming local status.

Surfing has always held a certain something for those interested in solitude. A crowded lineup is one of the main complaints around the world. No one likes to share waves, myself included.

Surfing also seems to have a general attraction for people who are environmentally conscious. I don’t know the numbers, but I’d wager that if someone did a survey, more surfers would (or at least say they would) be inclined towards a more earth conscious way of thinking, if only to keep our oceans pristine and those waves rolling in, which if you think about it, can be construed as another selfish pursuit. And that’s okay. Surfing is fun. Catching waves is fun. No one likes it when someone ruins their fun. But what if more people in the water meant a healthier planet?

A few weeks ago, I watched a video premiere of a ski film called All.I.Can. The premise of the film is simple: The more skiers that exist in the world, the more people will take an interest in the environment – specifically skiing environments. Interaction with nature lends itself to some kind of preservation instinct. If you’ve surfed for more than a day, you’ve probably had that moment. For me, it usually happens during a lull in sets. I’ll turn around, stop focusing on when the next wave is rolling through and where I need to be so that guy beside me doesn’t get it, and realize that things on our planet are pretty freaking nice. It’s a shame that we’re doing such a fantastic job of screwing it up.

So here’s something I’ll throw out there (outlandish as it may seem and as you may valiantly argue in the comments) in the interest of good conversation: what if promotion of our sport (think the predictably hated big businesses – Nike, Billabong, etc…), for whatever the reason (read: money) are actually a good thing in terms of the environment?

I posit that if there are more people in the water experiencing the “freaking nice planet” moment, then maybe more people will actively try to fix things. Sure, it might be taking some of the fun out of it for surfers who want the lineup to be completely devoid of humans (like me), but if what I’m saying is actually right (which is rare), I’m reasonably sure that those fleeting moments of solitude pale in comparison to the importance of fixing our leaky faucet of a planet.

Of course, as hypothetical as this whole thing may be, a comparison must be made between the amount of pollution the titans of industry produce versus the impact of increased awareness.  Awareness is an incredibly vague principle. People like me throw the term around as though it’s the end-all-be-all of solutions.  But it works, and here’s an example: In July of 2011, one of the most outspoken advocates of the environment, Greenpeace, launched a campaign called Detox. “Campaigning to stop industry poisoning waterways around the world with hazardous, persistent and hormone-disrupting chemicals,” Detox rustled the feathers of enough industry peacocks to get Nike, Adidas, Puma, and more to commit to staunching the flow of hazardous chemicals from its supply chain over the next eight years. That’s significant.

Greenpeace did this by pitting a few major companies against one another and making sure everyone knew about it. They employed all the gimmicks: a 600-person striptease that was (badly) synchronized across 29 cities, Snoop Dogg, break dancing, skateboarding… they even made up a fancy logo for the campaign. All in the name of awareness. Although I – and many – have a sneaking suspicion that the reasoning for joining a movement like this can be largely attributed to how the public perceives a company which, for an action sports company, directly relates to their bank account, it really doesn’t matter. Just so long as they’re doing it.

I love pulling up to an empty wave as much as the next guy, but I’d give that up if it meant never pulling up to that same empty wave, paddling out, catching a few waves, then spending the next few days draining my sinuses of toxic waste and dead fish particles. Or worse yet, watching that empty wave from the sand because, hey, did you see the sign? Toxic. Beaches Closed.

  • http://twitter.com/abohannon Adam Bohannon

    I started surfing 6 mos ago and I battle with this, often during the lulls in sets, like you explained. I love surfing. And I’m stoked that even at 27 I can find something new that I truly enjoy. But I can’t help but thinking that it is indeed selfish, especially with respect to the environment. Though I wish everyone knew how surfing could make you feel, what it was like to pull into a beautiful wave on a glassy day, and could experience the time you get to reflect out in the water by yourself, I always come back to this: more surfers = more boards, more wax, more fins, more wetsuits + accessories. Sure, we need to create these things in an environmentally sustainable way and I know many are made this way currently, but I’d assume there’s a crucial, irreplaceable step in that assembly line that is harmful to the environment and the more surfers there are, the more acute that damage becomes. And even if the production of these things could be 100% environmentally sustainable/friendly, what about the products we put on our bodies? Lotions, deodorants, hair products, sunscreen, etc. These are not details to be overlooked. En masse they harm the water equally as much. 

    Just chiming in for sake of discussion. I can also see your point of view, and I think that’s important. I’m a new surfer and totally enamored right now by the sport, but if this feeling of awe and love for the environment that I get from surfing can last even minimally into my future years, I’d say that’s a great thing – and even more so if this feeling can be spread around to all who surf.

  • Hasburgh

    This is some brilliant stuff, dude… surfing has turned me into a shit and a thief and a saint.  Everything that confuses me and pisses me off about the world or makes me smile in awe and wonder I can find in a crowded line up on a big day; the messages and the lessons are everywhere.

  • Al Baydough

    Sorry, not buying it. All you have to do is look at the disproportionate levels of attention paid to the various posts here and elsewhere that clearly shows that surfers, while certainly selfish, don’t really care about enviro issues. We’d rather obsess over Dane’s “hipsterism” than The Value of a Wave. It’s not even a contest (npi).

     And go down to the beach; watch the average surfer returning from a session to see how much trash he/she picks up on their way back to their car (I have been doing this myself for nearly as long as I’ve been surfing; tried to lead by example – had pretty much no impact). Over 90% don’t bother to pick up even one bit of trash – EVER. Pathetic. When I’m in the water I always grab the trash that floats by me (within reason) and stuff it in my wetsuit. I pass this on to people all the time to no avail. The other thing about the “selfishness” of wishing you were on that wave: generally speaking, when people watch a musician tear it up, an artist render a stunning work, a man/woman with an attractive partner, an athlete dazzle with agility we pretty much ALL wish we were that person. We are an inherently selfish and opportunistic species. Most of us just can’t seem to be content no matter how good we’ve got it. The sad fact of the matter is that the vast majority of people who engage nature nearly always leave it worse than they found it. That includes surfers and skiers and most other “lifestyle” activities.  It’s a shame. It really could be much better and different and it wouldn’t even require that much of a collective effort. Just imagine what the beaches and parks would look like if even 20% of the people visiting them picked up the trash they saw on their way back to their vehicles. Dare to dream.  

  • Andy French

    The only point you made that I’d contend is, “The sad fact of the matter is that the vast majority of people who engage nature nearly always leave it worse than they found it.”  Although you are most definitely right on that point I think that it would be much more beneficial to have people out and engaged in the natural environment (whether that be skiing, surfing, hiking, or whatever) even if they are leaving it worse than they found it.  I know, not ideal at all, in an ideal world everyone would be outside and leaving no trace.  My point being that people outside and engaged in nature are better than people inside and completely disengaged from nature.  

  • Jona Bouic

    If  every human being could surf, the planet would be safe, right?  Imagine 7 billion dudes on a lineup, could be a fun thing to watch…

  • Anonymous

    I tend to think of crowds as another source of pollution

  • Al Baydough

    Maybe. But the constant need to close national parks (like Yosemite) for cleanup and maintenance due to the negligence of visitors doesn’t bode well for your position. And every beach that suffers a tourist invasion looks like hell at the end of the day; these same a-holes then complain about having to pay taxes for services that are necessary in order to clean up after their sorry asses.

    The facts of the matter are not supporting your claim. I wish this were not true.

    Most people never grew beyond the terrible twos and don’t want to be “told what to do,” even if it benefits them and those they love. 

  • Tim Hamby

    Just FYI Al, yesterday I took a walk down the beach with my daughter and returned carrying (4) plastic bottles (3 waters and a French’s Mustard), as well as (1) rubber glove. To be perfectly honest, most times I would not have gone out of my way to retrieve those items, unless they were directly in my path at my local break. However, I had this movie trailer, this post and the subject in my mind. So I did it. Take that for what it’s worth.

    As far as being able to prove whether or not more surfers (or anyone using the environment for their enjoyment) equates to more environmental awareness and positive action, I’m guessing you can come up with an algorithm to quantify almost anything given the resources to conduct studies, and a little imagination.

    I do believe that great creative has the power to inspire and affect change and that the more inspired people there are (inspired either by great creative; participation in an sport or activity; or by others); the greater the odds that inspiration and positive actions will be passed along.

    I still haven’t seen All.I.Can, only the trailer (love this one -”Imagination” http://vimeo.com/32863936). I’m not even a skiier, but based just upon the previews, I do plan to buy this DVD. Cynics can say, “Aha! The producers sold you!” That’s tru. What’s also true is that they sold me on thinking more about the environment these past few weeks. And that was before I even saw this post. From what I’ve seen, everything about this film is brilliant- the concept, skiing, music, cinematography, editing… The way they portray pollution, de-forestation and a “suffocating” earth are all extremely powerful. The creative is simply so well-executed and emotionally compelling that I reacted to it. And I was stoked to see Alex post about it.

    I wrote about it briefly in my blog, posted about it on Facebook and saw other friends doing the same. Now, we’re talking about it here. And yesterday, I came home with bottles in my hand. My point is that people can be inspired to act. And as more influence behind a particular cause is thrown into the “thought stream” via news media, cinema, social networks, blogs, boards (and beach walks), the more synergy that builds to potentially transform thought to action.

  • Al Baydough

    Crowds SUCK:

     http://vimeo.com/34903457

  • Albino Unicorn

    This is a profound read and I have been of this mindeset for about 20 plus years now! The problem is that we need to reach those upstream and in the middle!
     The majority of people on the planet could never surf but should also be aware of their part in this world. Water is the connection…….. and it is why you see the same mentality in the mountain (snow) communities, because its at the sources of water that you find this respect.

    Money and the persuit of it takes the front seat in the majorities way of life with  a drunken consumption behind the stearing wheel. Pissing in the stream is over looked by those that are too busy with there pile of shinny! 

    Thanks for the read

    Albino Unicorn

  • Aaron

    I must not fit the mold because by example, Skip Frye, picks up trash before every session, I have seen him more than once to verify this. I have picked up trash at almost every session in  and filled my back seat floor while visiting Hawaii picking up styro foam… The ability to enjoy what you have is something that most people try to do… The awareness of this trial is by all means a worthy pursuit. If it were even 5% that would be worth the effort… And what if you had guys like Dane picking up trash… what if “hipster” stood for “hippy” and what if that translated to Popular surfers pushing for environmental causes… Rasta and Machado are not ones to forget, shaping even large industry giants to make more eco-friendly products. All and all if we can’t change than it won’t matter anyways, but if hipster can change than there is always hope! 

    http://www.odinasurf.com
    http://www.rerip.org
    http://www.sustainablesurf.org 
    the peoples movement
    Moss Research Surfboards
    Entropy Resins
    Eco Board Works
    Solid Surfboards

    PATAGONIA

    They are out there… consumers can make the change they want! Every dollar makes a difference! The easiest way to invest in change, is purchase from a company you support!

CONTRIBUTE* Join the planet's largest network of thinking surfers.
SUPPORT US* 10% goes to a charity of your choice